IFReviewed by Paul OBrian on 2006-07-20 09:03
"What-IF?" is an excellent name for this zcode file. The only one I can think of that would fit as well would be "Where's the IF?" Here's what happens when you run this file: you get a menu, asking you to select an "alternatate" history from a list of seven choices. When you make a selection, What-IF? spits out several screensful of text and then brings you back to the menu. That's it. No prompt (other than the menu prompt), no PC, no locations, no objects, really no game at all. Talk about your puzzleless IF!
Twisting the knife even further is the fact that all of these paragraphs are very, very badly written. Missing commas, misspellings, incorrect words, sentence fragments, misplaced modifiers, and many more errors make appearances over and over and over again. Here, I'll choose an example at random: "If knowledge of how the Chinese navigated had reached the West research in this field may not have preceded." Even if we ignore the fact that there should definitely be a comma between "West" and "research", we are still left with the question: preceded what?
This file has nothing to offer as IF. Its writing is difficult, sometimes impossible, to understand. It might make an interesting pamphlet, if somebody who is fluent in English gave it a major editorial overhaul. What it's doing in an interactive fiction competition remains an unanswered question.